Academic Journal
Structure without semantics: no evidence for bonobo compositionality in Berthet et al. (2025).
| Τίτλος: | Structure without semantics: no evidence for bonobo compositionality in Berthet et al. (2025). |
|---|---|
| Συγγραφείς: | Wartel A; Centre for Cultural Evolution, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden., Lind J; Centre for Cultural Evolution, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.; Department of Bird Ringing and Palynology, Swedish Museum of Natural History, Stockholm, Sweden., Kleberg JL; Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden., Tennie C; Faculty of Science, WG Early Prehistory and Quaternary Ecology, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany.; The Lester E. Fisher Center for the Study and Conservation of Apes, Lincoln Park Zoo, Chicago, Illinois, United States.; EXC 3101 'HUMAN ORIGINS-Cluster of Excellence for Integrative Human Origins Studies', University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany., Jonsson M; Centre for Cultural Evolution, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.; Department of Oncology-Pathology, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden., Jon-And A; Centre for Cultural Evolution, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.; Department of Romance Studies and Classics, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden., Ekström A; Centre for Cultural Evolution, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.; Speech, Music & Hearing, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden.; Department of Language Studies, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden. |
| Πηγή: | PeerJ [PeerJ] 2026 Aug 21; Vol. 14, pp. e21651. Date of Electronic Publication: 2026 Aug 21 (Print Publication: 2026). |
| Τύπος έκδοσης: | Journal Article |
| Γλώσσα: | English |
| Στοιχεία περιοδικού: | Publisher: PeerJ Inc Country of Publication: United States NLM ID: 101603425 Publication Model: eCollection Cited Medium: Internet ISSN: 2167-8359 (Electronic) Linking ISSN: 21678359 NLM ISO Abbreviation: PeerJ Subsets: MEDLINE |
| Imprint Name(s): | Original Publication: Corte Madera, CA : PeerJ Inc. |
| Ιατρικοί όροι (MeSH): | Pan paniscus*/physiology , Vocalization, Animal* , Semantics*, Animals |
| Περίληψη: | Understanding the evolutionary origins of combinatorial communication has motivated studies that analyse the semantic capacities of great ape vocal repertoires. A prominent example is the study by Berthet et al. (2025), which used Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA) on a large multidimensional dataset of bonobo calls and concluded that certain call combinations exhibit compositional meaning. We applied the published analytical pipeline to randomized datasets lacking any genuine association between call types and contextual features. Depending on implementation choices, the procedure identified significant relationships in 34.5-84.3% of simulations, suggesting substantial inflation of false-positive results. We therefore re-examined the statistical assumptions underlying the analysis itself. Because the MCA was constructed from repeated measures and uneven sampling across call types, its geometry reflects sampling frequencies and hierarchical dependencies in addition to any semantic structure. As such, any subsequent linear modelling of distances within this fixed space further violates assumptions of independence. We introduced a full permutation test in which a weighted MCA is recomputed under random reassignment of call-type labels, thereby generating a null distribution that respects the dependence structure of the data. Applying this procedure to the original dataset yielded a non-significant Monte Carlo p-value (p = 0.2597), indicating that the observed between-call-type separation does not exceed chance expectations. We argue that interpreting MCA distances as semantic relations requires theoretically motivated feature selection and dependence-aware inference, both of which are lacking in the original analysis. We conclude that Berthet et al. (2025) do not provide any statistically significant evidence for bonobo compositionality and highlight the broader limitations of relying on exploratory post-hoc statistical inference to identify semantic structure in animal communication. (© 2026 Wartel et al.) |
| Competing Interests: | The authors declare that they have no competing interests. |
| References: | Infect Immun. 2011 Oct;79(10):3855-9. (PMID: 21825063) PLoS Comput Biol. 2023 Dec 13;19(12):e1011702. (PMID: 38091352) Commun Biol. 2022 May 16;5(1):410. (PMID: 35577891) PLoS Biol. 2018 Aug 15;16(8):e2006425. (PMID: 30110319) Sci Am. 1960 Sep;203:89-96. (PMID: 14402211) Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2025 Oct;177:106342. (PMID: 40825455) Nat Commun. 2023 May 4;14(1):2225. (PMID: 37142584) Sci Adv. 2025 May 9;11(19):eadq2879. (PMID: 40344055) Nat Hum Behav. 2018 Jan;2(1):6-10. (PMID: 30980045) Science. 2025 Apr 04;388(6742):104-108. (PMID: 40179186) Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc. 2023 Feb;98(1):81-98. (PMID: 36189714) |
| Contributed Indexing: | Keywords: Evolution of language; Metascience; Primates; Statistics; Vocalization |
| Entry Date(s): | Date Created: 20260826 Date Completed: 20260826 Latest Revision: 20260827 |
| Update Code: | 20260827 |
| PubMed Central ID: | PMC13505523 |
| DOI: | 10.7717/peerj.21651 |
| PMID: | 42644090 |
| Βάση Δεδομένων: | MEDLINE |
καταχωρήστε σχόλιο πρώτοι!